Synthetic vs. Mineral Oil: Differences and Which is Better?

By | 17th July 2024
0 Comment

Synthetic vs. Mineral Oil: Differences and Which is Better?

Choosing the right engine oil is a crucial decision that can affect the durability and performance of your vehicle. Various types of oils are available on the market, including synthetic and mineral oils. This article will discuss the fundamental differences between these two types of oils, their advantages and limitations, and what factors to consider when deciding which oil to choose for your vehicle.

A comparison between synthetic oil and mineral oil for car engines. The image should be divided into two sections, one side representing synth

What is Synthetic Oil?

Synthetic oil is a specially developed engine oil that is manufactured through a chemical process using various compounds. It is characterized by a precisely controlled composition and uniform molecular structure, which allows for better properties compared to mineral oils.

The production process of synthetic oil typically uses high-grade base compounds that undergo advanced technologies such as polymerization, hydrosynthesis, or molecular distillation. These processes result in a more homogeneous and stable molecular structure, which translates into better engine protection and performance under various operating conditions.

Advantages of Synthetic Oil:

  1. Better flow properties at low temperatures, ensuring easier engine start-up in winter.
  2. Higher thermal and chemical stability, providing better protection against degradation and oxidation at high temperatures.
  3. Extended oil change intervals due to less tendency to accumulate deposits in the engine.
  4. Better protection against wear in extreme conditions, which is particularly important for high-power engines.

Synthetic oil can be used in both modern, technologically advanced engines and older designs. Its quality and properties usually meet the requirements of many car manufacturers, making it a popular choice in the automotive industry.

What is Mineral Oil?

Mineral oil is a traditional engine oil that is derived from natural raw materials, mainly crude oil. It consists primarily of a mixture of various organic compounds that are not subjected to advanced chemical processes, as is the case with synthetic oils.

The production process of mineral oil involves the distillation of crude oil, which separates it into different fractions with different boiling points. Then, various refining techniques are used to purify and obtain the appropriate viscosity range, and appropriate additives are added to improve its parameters.

Characteristics of Mineral Oil:

  1. Natural composition: Its base is natural raw materials, which may be considered an advantage by some users who prefer more traditional solutions.
  2. Economical: Mineral oil is usually cheaper to produce than synthetic oil, making it more accessible in the market and an attractive choice for those looking for an economical solution.
  3. Ease of adaptation to older engines: Mineral oil is often chosen for older vehicles that do not require technologically advanced oils, and using them does not negatively affect engine function.

Despite its advantages, mineral oil has some limitations compared to synthetic oils. It may be less stable in extreme temperature conditions and tends to accumulate deposits in the engine more quickly, which can affect its efficiency and durability.

Synthetic vs. Mineral Oil – Key Differences

  1. Composition and Production:
    • Synthetic oil is produced through advanced chemical processes, allowing precise control of composition and molecular structure.
    • Mineral oil is derived from natural raw materials, mainly crude oil, and is more diverse in composition.
  2. Flow Properties at Different Temperatures:
    • Synthetic oil has better flow properties at low temperatures, providing better engine protection during cold starts.
    • Mineral oil may have poorer flow properties at low temperatures, which can make engine start-up more difficult in cooler conditions.
  3. Thermal Stability and Durability:
    • Synthetic oil is more resistant to thermal degradation and oxidation compared to mineral oil, allowing for longer intervals between oil changes.
    • Mineral oil tends to accumulate deposits and contaminants in the engine more quickly, which can affect its efficiency and durability.
  4. Price:
    • Synthetic oil is usually more expensive to produce than mineral oil, which translates into a higher retail price.
    • Mineral oil is cheaper to produce and is usually a more economical choice.
  5. Applications:
    • Synthetic oil is recommended especially for modern, high-performance engines with advanced technology that require better protection and efficiency.
    • Mineral oil can be used in older vehicles that do not require technologically advanced oils.

Which is Better: Mineral or Synthetic Oil?

The choice between mineral and synthetic oil depends on many factors and may be influenced by individual preferences and the characteristics of the car’s engine. Both types of oils have their advantages and limitations, so it’s worth carefully considering which will be a better choice for a given vehicle.

Consider the following when making your choice:

Mineral Oil:

  • Is cheaper compared to synthetic oil, which may be attractive to those looking for economical solutions.
  • May work well in older vehicles that don’t require technologically advanced oils.
  • May be more readily available in the market.

Synthetic Oil:

  • Has better flow properties at low temperatures, allowing for easier engine start-up in winter.
  • Is more resistant to thermal degradation and oxidation, which translates into longer intervals between oil changes.
  • Provides better protection for modern, high-performance engines with advanced technology.

If you have a modern car with an advanced engine that requires better protection and efficiency, synthetic oil may be a better choice. It is recommended by many car manufacturers, especially for vehicles with high power ratings. Synthetic oil can also extend the period between oil changes, which translates into lower operating costs in the long run.

However, if you have an older vehicle and don’t require advanced oil properties, mineral oil may be a sufficient solution. It’s worth remembering, though, that regular oil changes and maintaining the engine’s condition are crucial, regardless of the oil choice.

The final decision should be based on the vehicle manufacturer’s recommendations, operating conditions, user preferences, and budget. It’s worth consulting with a mechanic or automotive specialist to choose the right oil that will best meet the requirements of your engine and ensure its long-term efficiency.